What is considered fraud in employee timekeeping?

Timekeeping fraud occurs when the system used does not reflect the current working hours of employees .

This can happen in different ways, both through direct manipulation and through unreliable systems.

Among the most frequent cases are:

• manual modification of work records

• signings made by another person

• false or incomplete records

• subsequent alteration of the recorded workday

• deletion of historical records

When this type of situation is detected during a labor inspection, it can be considered a serious or even very serious violation.

In these cases, the company must demonstrate that the system used guarantees reliable and verifiable records .

Why player transfer manipulation is a legal problem

Recording working hours is not just an administrative formality.

Its main objective is to guarantee real control of working time and prevent abuses related to unpaid overtime .

When records are manipulated, the system loses its value as legal evidence .

This means the company cannot properly demonstrate:

• How many hours did the employee actually work?

• if overtime was worked

• if mandatory rest periods are respected

• if the contract matches the current working hours

During a labor inspection, this situation may be interpreted as a breach of labor regulations .

You can find more information about how these inspections work here:

➡ Labor inspection: what they check during timekeeping

What sanctions can be applied?

When the Labor Inspectorate detects irregularities in the timekeeping records, it can impose financial penalties on the company .

Infringements related to timekeeping are usually classified as serious infringements under Spanish labor law .

Penalties may vary depending on:

• the seriousness of the breach

• the number of affected workers

• if there is recidivism or obvious fraud

In general terms, the penalties can be placed in the following approximate ranges:

Serious violations

Between 751 and 7,500 euros .

Very serious offenses

The penalties may exceed these figures depending on the case.

When the irregularity affects several workers, the penalties can be multiplied by each affected employee , which significantly increases the economic risk for the company.

You can see more details about the purposes here:

➡ How much is the fine for not registering working hours?

Frequent cases detected by the Labor Inspectorate

The Labor Inspectorate has identified several common patterns of fraud or manipulation in employee timekeeping.

Some of the most common ones include:

• Companies that fill out the time records at the end of the month

• systems where records can be manually modified

• employees who clock in for other colleagues

• records that always show the same entry and exit time

• absence of change history in the records

These patterns often raise suspicions during a workplace inspection .

When a company cannot properly justify the records, a sanctioning procedure may be initiated.

Problems with manual systems

Manual timekeeping systems tend to present more risks of manipulation or errors .

Among the most common problems are:

• registration forms that are filled out later

• lack of modification history

• records that can be easily altered

• absence of verifiable evidence

For this reason, many companies are replacing manual systems with digital timekeeping systems .

You can see a detailed comparison here:

➡ Digital vs paper timekeeping

Unintentional fraud in employee timekeeping

Not all irregularities in timekeeping are intentional.

In many cases, the problem arises because the company uses unclear systems or poorly defined processes .

For example:

• workers who forget to clock in

• incomplete records

• poorly documented manual corrections

• lack of control over records

When this type of error is repeated frequently, the inspection may consider that the system used is not reliable .

You can read more about this problem here:

➡ What happens if a worker doesn’t clock in for their workday?

How to avoid problems with time tracking

The best way to avoid penalties related to timekeeping is to use a system that guarantees reliable and verifiable records .

A suitable system should allow:

• record the workday in real time

• prevent unauthorized modifications

• maintain a complete record history

• generate clear reports for labor inspections

Digital time control systems allow these requirements to be met automatically and reduce the risk of errors or manipulation.

Time tracking for deployed workers

Timekeeping fraud or manipulation can also occur when workers perform their work outside the office .

This frequently occurs in sectors such as:

• construction

• cleaning

• technical facilities

• maintenance

• field services

In these cases, some digital systems allow verification of the location at the time of clocking in .

This helps to confirm that the timekeeping was actually carried out at the workplace , without the need for continuous monitoring of the employee.

You can find more information here:

➡ Time tracking with geolocation in Spain

Frequently asked questions about fraud in employee timekeeping

Can a company modify time records?

Modifications must be recorded and justified . Altering records without oversight may be considered labor fraud.

What happens if one employee signs for another?

This could be considered manipulation of the time record and cause problems during a labor inspection.

Are the sanctions applied per company or per employee?

In some cases, penalties may be applied for each affected worker , which increases the total amount of the fine.

How to prevent manipulation of the signing process?

Digital timekeeping systems reduce the risk of manipulation because they automatically record working hours and maintain a verifiable history.

Complies with labor regulations without risks

Implementing a reliable time tracking system helps avoid workplace penalties and simplifies the management of working hours.

With TimeGen you can:

• record working hours from your mobile phone

• manage employees and projects

• Generate automatic reports

• maintain historical records in accordance with the law

In this way, companies can comply with Spanish labor regulations without increasing the administrative burden .

Avoid legal problems and simplify your company’s time tracking.

Create a free account

Quick summary

Recording working hours is mandatory in Spain since the approval of Royal Decree-Law 8/2019 , which amended Article 34.9 of the Workers’ Statute .

This regulation requires all companies to record the start and end times of each worker’s working day .

The purpose of this obligation is:

• to guarantee control of working hours

• avoid abuses related to overtime

• improve transparency in labor relations

However, one of the most frequent problems detected by the Labor Inspectorate is the manipulation of the time record .

When records are altered or do not reflect the current working hours, the company may face significant labor penalties .

In some cases, these penalties can reach thousands of euros per affected worker .

You can consult the complete guide on this regulation here:

➡ Mandatory timekeeping in Spain